Political discussions on possible arms supplies to Ukraine are very heated in Germany. In this connection, a (still) hypothetical question arises: what legal consequences could it have for Germany if it trains Ukrainian soldiers to handle Western weapons.
An expert report prepared by the Bundestag’s scientific service examines whether this will make Germany a party to the war.
Ukraine has the right to defend itself against Russia
Experts in international law are unanimous that Russia’s war of conquest is a clear violation of the UN Charter’s ban on violence. Russia’s aggression was confirmed and condemned by the UN General Assembly, which called on Russia to withdraw its troops immediately. It follows that in the current situation Ukraine has the right to self-defense.
According to the UN Charter, this self-defense can be carried out “individually or collectively”. Ukraine has urged help, which under international law means that support for Ukraine from other countries is legitimate. This includes not only arms supplies but also the sending of troops. And although all other countries have ruled out this option, it would be acceptable under international law.
The question of when a country becomes a party to the war is not clear enough. However, it is clear that even if this happens, it does not automatically mean a violation of international law.
Arms supplies are not “participation in the war”
Many countries, including Germany, supply arms to Ukraine. International law is clear that arms supplies alone are not enough to make a country a participant in the war. Whether the training of foreign soldiers, in the case of the Ukrainians, changes this situation is not entirely clear.
Experts from the Bundestag’s economic department write that if the supply of weapons is accompanied by the training of foreign soldiers, it will probably “go beyond the guaranteed sphere of non-participation in hostilities”.
However, some experts in international law disagree. They believe that the training of military personnel does not indicate direct intervention in military conflict. According to Philippe Durr of the Institute of Public and International Law at the University of Bonn, only in the following two cases will Germany certainly become a country at war: if Russia invades Germany directly or if Germany sends troops to fight in Ukraine.
There are no other similar cases
Judgments on identical cases are very rare in history – when third countries have trained foreign soldiers to handle certain weapons systems. In 1986, the International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled that the United States had violated an international ban on military intervention by supporting Nicaraguan counter-attacks, including military training.
However, this case cannot be compared to the current war in Ukraine, as Nicaragua was a country of internal conflict. In other words, the Hague tribunal’s ruling on the Nicaraguan “counter” case could hardly be a guide to the situation in Ukraine.
In conclusion, from the point of view of international law, the issue of training foreign soldiers is not particularly controversial. Another question is what is the political assessment of such assistance. And here the opinions seriously differ.
Related Posts
- CIA: Putin may use tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine
The CIA believes that in the war in Ukraine, Russia may decide to use small-scale…
- Ukraine wants weapons to break the siege of Mariupol
Ukraine needs more weapons to break the siege of Mariupol. This was stated in a…
- Putin threatens "lightning strikes" in Ukraine's intervention and warns the West about weapons
Russian President Vladimir Putin has threatened with a "lightning" response against anyone who could intervene…
- The protests in Peru reflect the widespread impact of the war in Ukraine
A continuing wave of violent protests in Peru shows how the Russian invasion of Ukraine…
- The war in Ukraine: why do the Russians commit these atrocities?
The war is cruel and dirty. The idea that modern weapons can lead to a…
- Three scenarios for the war in Ukraine show that it will last
At the end of the sixth week of the war in Ukraine, the commander of…
- The threshold of genocide has been reached in Ukraine
The term "genocide" has accompanied Russia's war in Ukraine from the very beginning. It was…
- The sunset of the far-right in Ukraine. Why the Russian thesis about the war does not hold
"A gang of drug addicts and neo-Nazis." This is how Russian President Vladimir Putin described…
- The clash between the IT armies of Ukraine and Russia
Every day at 5 is local time the channel the "Telegram" of the IT Army…
- US Secretary of State: Ukraine succeeds, Russia fails
Russia is failing to win in Ukraine, said US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken, DPA…
More Stories
What are Europe’s alternatives if Russia does not release the gas
The Nord Stream 1 pipeline, which transports Russian gas to Germany, will undergo additional repair work, Gazprom said on Friday,...
The unknown about the attack in Crimea: not whether, but how Ukraine carried it out
The Russian Ministry of Defense's version of the explosion at the Saki air base in Crimea was met with skepticism...
According to Russia, the US is trying to blame it for the food crisis
Washington's attempts to shift responsibility for the world's food situation to Russia are absurd, said Russian Ambassador to the United...
The Russian economy is consolidating the downward trend
In May 2022, the Russian economy contracted by 4.3% on an annual basis after a decline of 2.8% in April,...
Airbnb, UPS, and Twitch have been fined for not storing personal data in Russia
A Russian court said on Tuesday it fined video streaming service Twitch, photo hosting Pinterest, holiday rental company Airbnb, and...
Why Turkey has been entering Europe for 60 years
The European Union is falling apart before it can embrace Turkey as its 29th member. This is the reality in...